COMMENTARY: Stop Scapegoating Mental Illness for Mass Violence


The following is the transcript of a video presentation by Jeffrey A. Lieberman, MD, which was published in MedScape on August 6, 2019:


Stop Scapegoating Mental Illness for Mass Violence

This transcript has been edited for clarity.

This past weekend, in a little over 24 hours, gun violence claimed the lives of 30 people and injured dozens more. Almost as tragic as the incidents themselves is the fact that mass shootings have become a routine part of life in America. It no longer feels unusual to turn on the news and see the mugshot of another angry young man who has committed another act of violence targeting multiple innocent victims, leaving behind nothing but an angry manifesto, a trail of dead and wounded bodies, and a host of unanswered questions.

In the aftermath of these incidents, an all-too-familiar scenario unfolded. The media and public erupted in outrage and emitted cries of “never again.” After the chest-thumping died down, the soul-searching began and the requisite question of “why” was asked, along with calls for action to prevent such events in the future. Politicians and pundits then solemnly weigh in with sanctimonious platitudes, and eventually the argument devolves into the familiar refrain of name-calling and partisan bickering, where no consensus is ever reached and nothing is done to prevent these shootings from happening in the future.

In this political theater, mental illness too often becomes the convenient scapegoat that is used to deflect attention from other causes, such as the NRA, ineffective gun control laws, a culture of hate, and the lack of respect for morals and laws. However, the data expose the mendacity of this claim. In 2019 alone, there have been 255 reported and verified mass shootings in the United States. These happen in the places we visit in our communities every single day, from schools and religious institutions to shopping malls and movie theaters.

The perpetrators of these crimes are uniformly male and can be categorized by their motivations: ideology, disgruntled at work, disaffected loners, and untreated persons with mental illness. A recent white paper by an expert group of mental health providers, law enforcement officials, and educators, commissioned by the National Council on Behavioral Health, found that approximately 25% of the perpetrators were mentally ill and their symptoms appeared to be a motivating factor. They suffered from a relatively small number of disorders, including psychotic, mood, and PTSD. Thus 75% of mass murders were caused by people doing so for reasons other than mental illness. Moreover, the main diagnoses of those mentally ill perpetrators have comparable frequencies of males and females being affected, yet almost 100% of the culprits were male. This clearly implicates other factors in prompting people to commit these heinous crimes, such as ready access to weapons, a permissive culture with relaxed restrictions that encourages individual expression, the Internet, ubiquitous exposure to violence in the entertainment media, and the prevalence of recreational intoxicants.

Another analysis, reported in The New York Times, “What Explains U.S. Mass Shootings? International Comparisons Suggest an Answer,” disentangled the variables of mental illness, treatment, and violence. It found that the rates of severe mental illness and crime in the United States are comparable to those seen in other wealthy countries. Yet crime in America was found to be more lethal due to the greater availability of guns.

I find it ironic that psychiatrists should have to caution people not to falsely pathologize objectionable behavior when we are so often accused of broadening the DSM boundaries by doing the same. It’s also reminiscent of the slippery slope of using mental illness as a scapegoat for politically dissident or potentially dangerous behaviors.

In America we pay a price for our cultural openness and individual freedoms of beliefs and expression. We are the engine of the world’s innovation and creativity. However, there is a dark side to this unless we do something to stop it.

451 thoughts on “COMMENTARY: Stop Scapegoating Mental Illness for Mass Violence”

  1. Pingback: viagra express delivery

  2. Pingback: generic cialis

  3. Pingback: printable cialis coupon

  4. Pingback: cialis daily cost

  5. Pingback: Viagra mail order usa

  6. Pingback: Buy viagra in us

  7. Pingback: cialis 20

  8. Pingback: buy cialis canada

  9. Pingback: cialis coupon cvs

  10. Pingback: discount cialis

  11. Pingback: viagra generic

  12. Pingback: mens erection pills

  13. Pingback: cheapest ed pills

  14. Pingback: ed pills that really work

  15. Pingback: walmart pharmacy

  16. Pingback: canadian pharmacy

  17. Pingback: Get cialis

  18. Pingback: Cialis in usa

  19. Pingback: buy vardenafil online

  20. Pingback: levitra canada

  21. Pingback: vardenafil for sale

  22. Pingback: casino moons online casino

  23. Pingback: viagra for women

  24. Pingback: best real casino online

  25. Pingback: best online casino usa

  26. Pingback: loans online

  27. Pingback: quick cash loans

  28. Pingback: viagra pills

  29. Pingback: cialis 5 mg

  30. Pingback: party casino online nj

  31. Pingback: visiter le site web de l'utilisateur

  32. Pingback: play blackjack online casino

  33. Pingback: hard rock casino online

  34. Pingback: cialis to buy

  35. Pingback: cialis to buy

  36. Pingback: generic for cialis

  37. Pingback: buy generic viagra online

  38. Pingback: real money casino games

  39. Pingback: casino games

  40. Pingback: online gambling

  41. Pingback: viagra for sale

  42. Pingback: buy viagra now

  43. Pingback: viagra buy

  44. Pingback: viagra sample

  45. Pingback: can i buy viagra online

  46. Pingback: viagra cost

  47. Pingback: generic cialis tadalafil best buys

  48. Pingback: viagra australia

  49. Pingback: purchase viagra online canada

  50. Pingback: buy viagra online usa

  51. Pingback: discount generic viagra

  52. Pingback: buy viagra online cheap

  53. Pingback: canadian pharmacy viagra

  54. Pingback: viagra

  55. Pingback: illegal buy viagra online

  56. Pingback: cheap viagra

  57. Pingback: buy hydroxychloroquine

  58. Pingback: buy viagra

  59. Pingback: buy viagra online

  60. Pingback: Viagra 200 mg without a doctor prescription

  61. Pingback: Viagra 200mg australia

  62. Pingback: Viagra 200mg pills

  63. Pingback: where can i buy Viagra 120 mg

  64. Pingback: tadalafil pills

  65. Pingback: Viagra 200 mg generic

  66. Pingback: buy sildenafil online

  67. Pingback: cialis online pharmacy

  68. Pingback: viagra prices

  69. Pingback: order Cialis 80 mg

  70. Pingback: Cialis 40mg generic

  71. Pingback: tadalafil

  72. Pingback: viagra dosage

  73. Pingback: Cialis 40 mg nz

  74. Pingback: cheap cialis

  75. Pingback: Cialis 80mg pills

  76. Pingback: otc viagra

  77. Pingback: Cialis 10 mg cost

  78. Pingback: viagra online for sale

  79. Pingback: Cialis 80mg for sale

  80. Pingback: Cialis 40mg usa

  81. Pingback: Cialis 10 mg medication

  82. Pingback: sildenafil 120mg otc

  83. Pingback: generic cialis

  84. Pingback: tadalafil 40mg uk

  85. Pingback: canadian rx pharmacy

  86. Pingback: levitra 60 mg no prescription

  87. Pingback: buy lasix 100 mg

  88. Pingback: furosemide 100 mg united states

  89. Pingback: propecia 5mg online pharmacy

  90. Pingback: best canadian pharmacy

  91. Pingback: lexapro 20mg united kingdom

  92. Pingback: online viagra

  93. Pingback: viagra cheap

  94. Pingback: buy viagra online

  95. Pingback: cheap abilify 20mg

  96. Pingback: actos 15 mg coupon

  97. Pingback: viagra sans ordonnance

  98. Pingback: aldactone 100mg without a prescription

  99. Pingback: allegra 120 mg united states

  100. Pingback: order allopurinol 300mg

  101. Pingback: amaryl 4mg tablets

  102. Pingback: amoxicillin 500 mg price

  103. Pingback:

  104. Pingback: order ampicillin 500mg

  105. Pingback: cheapest antabuse 250 mg

  106. Pingback: arava 10 mg over the counter

  107. Pingback: strattera 25 mg cost

  108. Pingback: aricept 10mg tablet

  109. Pingback: pay for viagra with paypal

  110. Pingback: cheap arimidex 1 mg

  111. Pingback: how to purchase tamoxifen 20 mg

  112. Pingback: order cialis

  113. Pingback: ashwagandha 60caps cheap

  114. Pingback: buy cialis

  115. Pingback: atarax 10mg coupon

  116. Pingback: augmentin 875/125mg tablet

  117. Pingback: avapro 300 mg united states

  118. Pingback: Pills Without a Doctor Prescription

  119. Pingback: avodart 0,5 mg medication

  120. Pingback: is generic viagra the same

  121. Pingback: baclofen 25mg prices

  122. Pingback: where to buy bactrim 800/160 mg

  123. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg

  124. Pingback: benicar 20 mg over the counter

  125. Pingback: cialis bayer

  126. Pingback: viagra without a doctor prescription

  127. Pingback: Biaxin 250 mg pharmacy

  128. Pingback: cheapest Premarin 0,3 mg

  129. Pingback: cialis spray

  130. Pingback: viagra for women

  131. Pingback: brand viagra without prescription

  132. Pingback: buy cialis online

  133. Pingback: casodex tablet

  134. Pingback: catapres 100 mcg united states

  135. Pingback: ceclor no prescription

  136. Pingback: buy viagra online

  137. Pingback: ceftin pharmacy

  138. Pingback: celebrex tablets

  139. Pingback: sildenafil generic

  140. Pingback: celexa generic

  141. Pingback: errection problems

  142. Pingback: where to buy cephalexin 500 mg

  143. Pingback: cipro uk

  144. Pingback: buy viagra online

  145. Pingback: online gambling

  146. Pingback: casino world

  147. Pingback: pala casino online

  148. Pingback: real online casino

  149. Pingback: slot games online

  150. Pingback: red dog casino

  151. Pingback: slots real money

  152. Pingback: Cheap Erection Pills

  153. Pingback: casino online usa

  154. Pingback: casino world

  155. Pingback: real money online casino

  156. Pingback: car insurance quotes online

  157. Pingback: allstate car insurance

  158. Pingback: commercial car insurance quotes companies

  159. Pingback: top car insurance quotes companies

  160. Pingback: to buy viagra in toronto

  161. Pingback: generic cialis for sale

  162. Pingback: costco car insurance quotes

  163. Pingback: insurance for young drivers

  164. Pingback: hartford car insurance quotes

  165. Pingback: tadalafil cialis

  166. Pingback: personal car insurance

  167. Pingback: best car insurance

  168. Pingback: buy cialis

  169. Pingback: insurance rates

  170. Pingback: mens ed pills

  171. Pingback: easy personal loans

  172. Pingback: payday loans near me

  173. Pingback: top ed pills

  174. Pingback: erectile dysfunction drugs for sale

  175. Pingback: installment loans near me

  176. Pingback: quick loans in ga

  177. Pingback: bad credit loans oxnard ca

  178. Pingback: viagra buy online

  179. Pingback: payday payday loans online

  180. Pingback: amoxicillin pills 500 mg

  181. Pingback: personal loans near me

  182. Pingback: cbd oil for pain relief from ra

  183. Pingback: does walgreens sell cbd oil

  184. Pingback: cbd oil side effects stomach pain gas

  185. Pingback: generic cialis buy

  186. Pingback: sildenafil 20 mg tablets coupon

  187. Pingback: cbd oil products

  188. Pingback: generic viagra canada pharmacy

  189. Pingback: buying sildenafil uk

  190. Pingback: cbd oil for anxiety reviews

  191. Pingback: viagra cost in uk

  192. Pingback: how long does it take for cbd oil to work

  193. Pingback: personal loans for bad credit

  194. Pingback: cbd oil for pain relief where to buy

  195. Pingback: buy levitra using paypal

  196. Pingback: health benefits of cbd oil

  197. Pingback: sildenafil 25 mg tablet price

  198. Pingback: hempworks cbd oil

  199. Pingback: custom essays

  200. Pingback: buy levitra 10 mg

  201. Pingback: writer essay

  202. Pingback: viagra youtube

  203. Pingback: white paper writer

  204. Pingback: Brand name viagra

  205. Pingback: can you buy viagra over the counter usa

  206. Pingback: essay writing service cheap

  207. Pingback: online essay writing service

  208. Pingback: write an essay

  209. Pingback: middle school homework

  210. Pingback: assignment of leases

  211. Pingback: sildenafil 5 mg tablet

  212. Pingback: essays writing

  213. Pingback: buy custom essay

  214. Pingback: cost of clomid 50mg

  215. Pingback: can i buy sildenafil citrate

  216. Pingback: Levitra or viagra

  217. Pingback: buy clonidine

  218. Pingback: cialis uso corretto

  219. Pingback: clozaril 100mg over the counter

  220. Pingback: colchicine canada

  221. Pingback: how to purchase symbicort inhaler 160/4,5 mcg

  222. Pingback: Order viagra us

  223. Pingback: combivent coupon

  224. Pingback: coreg 3,12 mg tablets

  225. Pingback: help 123 essay

  226. Pingback: compazine 5mg tablet

  227. Pingback: cialis

  228. Pingback: order cialis online us

  229. Pingback: coumadin united states

  230. Pingback: cozaar without a doctor prescription

  231. Pingback: viagra interactions

  232. Pingback:

  233. Pingback: viagra spray for men

  234. Pingback: crestor prices

  235. Pingback: best custom essays

  236. Pingback: mba essay help

  237. Pingback: cymbalta 60 mg cheap

  238. Pingback: essay writing services review

  239. Pingback: buy viagra

  240. Pingback: master thesis writing service

  241. Pingback: buy dapsone caps

  242. Pingback: need someone write my paper

  243. Pingback: custom research papers writing service

  244. Pingback: thesis guidelines

  245. Pingback: ddavp online

  246. Pingback: Overnight delivery viagra

  247. Pingback: buy depakote 500mg

  248. Pingback: diamox tablet

  249. Pingback: differin 15g pills

  250. Pingback: diltiazem 60mg over the counter

  251. Pingback: cost of doxycycline 100mg

  252. Pingback: viagra

  253. Pingback: dramamine online pharmacy

  254. Pingback: cost of elavil 25 mg

  255. Pingback: erythromycin 500mg online

  256. Pingback: online pharmacy canada

  257. Pingback: etodolac online

  258. Pingback: Prednisone sale

  259. Pingback: flomax united states

  260. Pingback: flonase nasal spray pharmacy

  261. Pingback: garcinia cambogia caps usa

  262. Pingback: erectile dysfunction treatments

  263. Pingback: geodon online pharmacy

  264. Pingback: order cheap cialis online

  265. Pingback: cost of hyzaar

  266. Pingback: imdur pills

  267. Pingback: cialis and alcohol

  268. Pingback: cialis without a doctor prescription

  269. Pingback: cialis price

  270. Pingback: viagra online

  271. Pingback: imitrex australia

  272. Pingback: imodium 2 mg generic

  273. Pingback: cheap viagra

  274. Pingback: otc viagra

  275. Pingback: amazon viagra

  276. Pingback: Recommended Site

  277. Pingback: how much icariin equals viagra

  278. Pingback: how long for viagra to work

  279. Pingback: canadian pharmacies online

  280. Pingback: imuran coupon

  281. Pingback: indocin prices

  282. Pingback: generic zithromax over the counter

  283. Pingback: lamisil 250mg pharmacy

  284. Pingback: levaquin online pharmacy

  285. Pingback: buy viagra online

  286. Pingback: lopid uk

  287. Pingback: generic viagra 100mg

  288. Pingback: lopressor online pharmacy

  289. Pingback: where to buy luvox

  290. Pingback: macrobid 100mg cost

  291. Pingback: meclizine 25mg generic

  292. Pingback: genuine viagra best price

  293. Pingback: top erection pills

  294. Pingback: mestinon 60 mg coupon

  295. Pingback: Medex

  296. Pingback: micardis 80mg usa

  297. Pingback: pharmacy prices

  298. Pingback: viagra online canadian pharmacy

  299. Pingback: Zovirax

  300. Pingback: cost of mobic

  301. Pingback: discount drugs online pharmacy

  302. Pingback: motrin over the counter

  303. Pingback: Isoptin

  304. Pingback: online pharmacy canada

  305. Pingback: how to purchase nortriptyline 25 mg

  306. Pingback: periactin generic

  307. Pingback: phenergan prices

  308. Pingback: how to purchase plaquenil

  309. Pingback: canada drugs

  310. Pingback: cost of prevacid 30mg

  311. Pingback: prilosec 40 mg otc

  312. Pingback: where can i buy proair inhaler

  313. Pingback: buy viagra online

  314. Pingback: procardia pharmacy

  315. Pingback: buy cheap viagra

  316. Pingback: protonix without prescription

  317. Pingback: provigil without a doctor prescription

  318. Pingback: pulmicort 200 mcg price

  319. Pingback: amoxicillin 500mg

  320. Pingback: viagra similar products

  321. Pingback: pyridium price

  322. Pingback: reglan 10mg tablet

  323. Pingback: doxycycline pills

  324. Pingback: cheapest remeron 15 mg

  325. Pingback: retin-a cream medication

  326. Pingback: benadryl brand name in india

  327. Pingback: revatio 20 mg cheap

  328. Pingback: allegra in uk

  329. Pingback: risperdal uk

  330. Pingback: robaxin 500 mg united kingdom

  331. Pingback: rogaine 5% without a prescription

  332. Pingback: seroquel 100mg pharmacy

  333. Pingback: singulair usa

  334. Pingback: skelaxin pills

  335. Pingback: generic viagra cost

  336. Pingback: spiriva 9 mcg online pharmacy

  337. Pingback: tenormin tablet

  338. Pingback: viagra over the counter

  339. Pingback: thorazine uk

  340. Pingback: toprol purchase

  341. Pingback: tricor pharmacy

  342. Pingback: valtrex otc

  343. Pingback: verapamil 40 mg for sale

  344. Pingback: voltaren pills

  345. Pingback: wellbutrin 150mg canada

  346. Pingback: zanaflex 2mg for sale

  347. Pingback: zestril 5 mg cheap

  348. Pingback: cialis ads

  349. Pingback: buy zithromax 500 mg

  350. Pingback: Learn More Here

  351. Pingback: zocor without a doctor prescription

  352. Pingback: buy zithromax online cheap

  353. Pingback: cheapest zovirax 400 mg

  354. Pingback: zyloprim tablet

  355. Pingback: zyprexa cost

  356. Pingback: viagra jet lag

  357. Pingback: zyvox united states

  358. Pingback: how to buy sildenafil

  359. Pingback: tadalafil purchase

  360. Pingback: furosemide 100 mg online pharmacy

  361. Pingback: amoxicillin from canada

  362. Pingback: escitalopram 5 mg purchase

  363. Pingback: aripiprazole 20mg united kingdom

  364. Pingback: how to purchase pioglitazone 30 mg

  365. Pingback: spironolactone cheap

  366. Pingback: canadian drug pharmacy

  367. Pingback: glimepiride generic

  368. Pingback: cheap meclizine 25mg

  369. Pingback: leflunomide online pharmacy

  370. Pingback: atomoxetine nz

  371. Pingback: where can i buy donepezil 10 mg

  372. Pingback: anastrozole 1 mg price

  373. Pingback: generic viagra

  374. Pingback: irbesartan 300mg tablet

  375. Pingback: dutasteride without a doctor prescription

  376. Pingback: cheap olmesartan 40 mg

  377. Pingback: where can i buy buspirone

  378. Pingback: cefuroxime canada

  379. Pingback: cheapest citalopram

  380. Pingback: no rx cialis

  381. Pingback: cephalexin canada

  382. Pingback: soft gel cialis

  383. Pingback: cialis coupon

  384. Pingback: cheapest ciprofloxacin

  385. Pingback: loratadine 10 mg online pharmacy

  386. Pingback: cialis online

  387. Pingback: daily cialis reviews

  388. Pingback: order clindamycin 300mg

  389. Pingback: order clozapine

  390. Pingback: prochlorperazine 5mg generic

  391. Pingback: buy generic viagra here

  392. Pingback: carvedilolmg usa

  393. Pingback: viagra or cialis or levitra trial

  394. Pingback: warfarin 1mg canada

  395. Pingback: rosuvastatin 5 mg prices

  396. Pingback: buy cialis drug

  397. Pingback: trazodone tablet

  398. Pingback: tolterodine tablets

  399. Pingback: sildenafil 100 coupon

  400. Pingback: acetazolamide price

  401. Pingback: cheap generic cialis online

  402. Pingback: cheapest fluconazole 50mg

  403. Pingback: phenytoin uk

  404. Pingback: order oxybutynin 2.5 mg

  405. Pingback: cialis 20mg usa

  406. Pingback: where to buy doxycycline

  407. Pingback: bisacodyl 5mg no prescription

  408. Pingback: venlafaxinemg canada

  409. Pingback: generic viagra on line

  410. Pingback: generic viagra

  411. Pingback: amitriptyline 50mg nz

  412. Pingback: buy permethrin

  413. Pingback: cost of erythromycin 500mg

  414. Pingback: generic tadalafil 20mg

  415. Pingback: 141generic2Exare

  416. Pingback: buy cialis online 5mg

  417. Pingback: jwmefegp

  418. Pingback: estradiol for sale

  419. Pingback: etodolac 400mg without a prescription

  420. Pingback: buy cialis now

  421. Pingback: buy ed pills online

  422. Pingback: how to purchase tamsulosin 0.4 mg

  423. Pingback: ed meds

  424. Pingback: alendronate 35 mg cheap

  425. Pingback: what are cialis pills

  426. Pingback: canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg

  427. Pingback: nitrofurantoin 100mg canada

  428. Pingback: wat kost cialis 20 mg bij de apotheek

  429. Pingback: what does ivermectin overdose look like in a dog?

  430. Pingback: how much is viagra

  431. Pingback: glipizide 10 mg pharmacy

  432. Pingback: generic viagra best supplier

  433. Pingback: buy lasix online

  434. Pingback: tinidazole tablets

  435. Pingback: isosorbide for sale

  436. Pingback: buy chloramphenicol online

  437. Pingback: sumatriptan coupon

  438. Pingback: order zithromax

  439. Pingback: buy augmentin generic

  440. Pingback: buy loperamide

  441. Pingback: cialis comprar online

  442. Pingback: azathioprine 25 mg online pharmacy

  443. Pingback: cialis without prescriptions canada

  444. Pingback: average price cialis

  445. Pingback: cheap propranolol 10 mg

  446. Pingback: canadien cialis

  447. Pingback: buy cialis online in canada

  448. Pingback: viagra prices

  449. Pingback: canada cialis online

  450. Pingback: how to buy lamotrigine 100mglamotrigine cost

  451. Pingback: terbinafine canada

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top